The new Moynihan train hall is a “temple to modern mediocrity”
Posted on
Aaron Gordon, writing for Vice, about what the rehabilitation of the Farley Post Office with private office space means, and the triumph of “privately owned public spaces”:
The project’s backers have argued the private development was the only way to make it viable, and so it is either a smaller train hall with lots of office space or no train hall at all. But this, like many other aspects of urban development schemes, demonstrates a lamentable lack of imagination. The total cost, which includes funding from Amtrak, a federally funded agency, was $1.6 billion, a lot of money by any measure but hardly insurmountable for a project with local, state, and federal financing, and about half of the original Penn Station’s cost in inflation-adjusted dollars. Like so many other redevelopment projects in the city over recent decades, this whole project is not about palaces by and for the people. It is about “economic development,” and the people get a little something for the trouble of selling off a massively valuable real estate asset that we used to own.
And who is the lessee of the nearly 700,000 square feet of previously public space that has been so unceremoniously and garishly privatized? Facebook, of course.